Comparing The Best Portable Machines to Save on Oil Costs in 2024

Published: January 15, 2024

Best Value: MirOil BD505
Worst Value: FryClone 259FLTRM50

The Pitco P14 portable filter machine has earned its fair share of positive reviews, thanks to its user-friendly design and reliable pumping efficiency, standing resilient against frequent breakdowns. Boasting features a pump rate of 5.6GPM and utilizing flat filter paper (sold separately), it still raises the question: is almost $5500 CAD justified for this portable filter machine? Moreover, the sustainability rating doesn’t shine as it leans on filter paper instead of more environmentally friendly, reusable options. Plus, the use of filter paper requires more cleanup time after filtering. While it’s well-constructed, the combination of horsepower specifications and the use of filter paper leaves room for debate on whether this product truly delivers enough value for the price.

While the FryClone 259FLTRM50 portable filter machine comes with a budget-friendly price tag, the savings may come at a cost. The majority of reviews for this filter machine lean towards the negative, citing sluggish oil pumping of only 2GPM despite its electric filter pump designation, susceptibility to clogging, and a limited lifespan of just a few months before encountering breakdowns, say customers. Its sustainability rating is notably low at 1/5, attributable to a slow and inefficient motor pump with the use of filter paper over reusable alternatives – echoing concerns previously raised with the Pitco P14 portable filter machine. Despite its affordability, the issues reported by users warrant careful consideration before investing in the FryClone 259FLTRM50 portable filter machine. 

Highlighted by features such as a commendable pump rate of 4 GPM and a reversible 2-way pump for both draining and refilling fryers, the FryMaster PF50PR portable filter machine exhibits positive attributes. However, similar to its counterparts, numerous customer reviews express concerns about its durability, citing instances of the motor malfunctioning within a few months or encountering leakage issues. In line with the Pitco and FryClone filter machines, the FryMaster PF50PR also relies on filter paper, resulting in a comparatively low sustainability rating. Positioned as the second most expensive option among the four, it is advisable to approach an investment in the FryMaster PF50PR with careful consideration, weighing both its features and reported issues.

The MirOil BD505 portable filter machine stands out with its high-volume electric pump, boasting one of the fastest rates in the market at 5 GPM. Its rugged coated steel oil pan, equipped with clips for secure oil transportation, adds an extra layer of safety. Originating from the USA, this filter machine has earned a reputation for being exceptionally durable, experiencing minimal breakdowns despite its affordable price of $2,940.73 CAD.

While it has a one-way pump limitation, it surpasses the competition with an outstanding sustainability rating. Utilizing reusable filter bags (included with purchase), these bags can withstand up to 1500 uses in hot oil, a notable eco-friendly alternative to disposable filter paper. Plus, when filter machines typically break down, your frying oil will suffer until the pump is fixed correct? Yes in most cases, however the BD505 allow the removal of the filter basin (pot) and reusable hand-held filter to continue filtering without skipping a beat. Without a doubt, the BD505 portable filter machine emerges as the top choice for those seeking a swift, secure, durable, and sustainable solution for fryers with a 50lb capacity.

In conclusion, of all the portable filter machines the Pitco P14 boasts the fastest pump rate at 5.6 GPM, but its overall value is diminished by the necessity of disposable filter paper, raising questions about its cost-effectiveness. Conversely, the FryClone 259FLTRM50, as the most economical choice, falls short due to its sluggish 2 GPM pump rate and perceived poor quality. Similarly, despite the FryMaster PF50PR being the sole option with a 2-way pump, its subpar quality undermines its merits as a worthwhile investment.

On the contrary, the MirOil BD505 stands as a superior choice, surpassing the competition with its introduction of reusable filter bags and frames (included in the purchase), coupled with a rapid 5 GPM pump rate and a durable construction built to withstand the test of time.